from the whirlpool.net.au discussion forums
web hosting by WebCentral Australia
   acronis true image vs ghost View full version
User #148465   1948 posts
Whirlpool Enthusiast

Quick question..

hows does Acronis TrueImage 10 home create a full image of a hard drive while it is in windows?

When you use ghost you have to create the image before windows loads (boot from floppy)

so how can Acronis create a full image of everything (including windows) when it is in windows and a lot of files would be in use...

thanks

posted 2007-Apr-20, 9pm AEST
User #75484   68 posts
Forum Regular

dunno but acronis true image 10 works a treat
reinstall windows under 8min :D

posted 2007-Apr-20, 9pm AEST
User #32665   3506 posts
Whirlpool Forums Addict

ChubbyFingers writes...

dunno but acronis true image 10 works a treat
reinstall windows under 8min :D


Another vote here for the speed of ACT in restoring HDD and/or partitions.
My initial Backup Image (clean) is 4.77 GB and my Incremental Backup Image is 5.40 GB and works treat when and if needed.

I have no idea how the program works all I know is that it does do what it claims.

posted 2007-Apr-20, 11pm AEST
edited 2007-Apr-20, 11pm AEST
User #109339   1235 posts
Whirlpool Enthusiast

true image and disk director are the best. we use them alot. (bootable and non-bootable).

posted 2007-Apr-20, 11pm AEST
User #148465   1948 posts
Whirlpool Enthusiast

ChubbyFingers writes...

dunno but acronis true image 10 works a treat
reinstall windows under 8min :D


thats the home edition?

So you've created an image then reinstalled windows completely from that image? I suppose your would need to boot from the CD to restore the image....

posted 2007-Apr-21, 10am AEST
User #145127   55 posts
Forum Regular

rakem writes...

so how can Acronis create a full image of everything (including windows) when it is in windows and a lot of files would be in use...

It is only only copying files.

posted 2007-Apr-21, 10am AEST
User #145127   55 posts
Forum Regular

rakem writes...

So you've created an image then reinstalled windows completely from that image? I suppose your would need to boot from the CD to restore the image....

You can start the reinstall from within Windows. Acronis will reboot before starting reinstall.

If you use Acronis Secure Zone, you can access it by pressing F11 before Windows loads. Also you can use Acronis boot disk if you can't start Windows.

posted 2007-Apr-21, 10am AEST
User #159761   1431 posts
In the penalty box

Acronis TrueImage is amazing. Imho, the best on the market.

It makes an image of my Vista partition and my linux ext3 partitions. And it restores them beautifully :-)

Highly recommended for the price. Worth it!

posted 2007-Apr-21, 11am AEST
edited 2007-Apr-21, 11am AEST
User #56672   814 posts
Whirlpool Enthusiast

Acronis TrueImage 10 for me. Works a treat. :D

posted 2007-Apr-21, 12pm AEST
User #164114   387 posts
Forum Regular

Ghost gives you choice to disk image dimension which can be smaller that Acronis

posted 2007-Apr-21, 1pm AEST
User #75484   68 posts
Forum Regular

rakem writes...

thats the home edition?

So you've created an image then reinstalled windows completely from that image? I suppose your would need to boot from the CD to restore the image....


yes its the home version and you can make a boot cd for it then select the .tib file on your hdd, network or dvd

posted 2007-Apr-21, 4pm AEST
edited 2007-Apr-21, 4pm AEST
User #159761   1431 posts
In the penalty box

vaint writes...

Ghost gives you choice to disk image dimension which can be smaller that Acronis

Can you please elaborate?

posted 2007-Apr-21, 5pm AEST
User #56672   814 posts
Whirlpool Enthusiast

vaint writes...

Ghost gives you choice to disk image dimension which can be smaller that Acronis

If you mean Image size, Acronis allows you select varying degree of compression of which the end result is different overall Image file size. : D

posted 2007-Apr-22, 5am AEST
User #7405   240 posts
Forum Regular

Another vote for Acronis here.

One of the great advantages of using Acronis, is that it lets you back up specific files and folders if needed. It also allows you to mount the Acronis image as a virtual drive, and copy/paste files from it with ease.

One big advantage of Acronis, is that you can create an image of the HDD while booted in Windows.

It's worth spending your dollars on Acronis rather than ghost. Ghost seems to be outdated now, as Symantec really haven't updated that much.

posted 2007-Apr-22, 8am AEST
User #159761   1431 posts
In the penalty box

fenryr writes...

Ghost seems to be outdated now, as Symantec really haven't updated that much.

In all fairness to Symantec , its not that ghost is outdated, they actually have a newer version, but its now called "Save & Restore".

However, having said that, Acronis TrueImage is the best. Its professional and well designed and reliable and solid.

And I love the ability to create encrypted hidden partitions on my Hard Drive to store an image. And at boot, I can press a key combo and restore image anytime. Really professional package indeed.

I STRONGLY recommend Acronis TrueImage. Small investment for a fantastic product

posted 2007-Apr-22, 9am AEST
edited 2007-Apr-22, 9am AEST
User #164114   387 posts
Forum Regular

lisalisa writes...

In all fairness to Symantec

I was Symantec's fan at the time of Windows 98 II but now I really disagree with them.

I've had chance to try both Ghost and TrueImage and a part Acronis's undiscussed abilities, I found that Ghost makes much smaller images.

posted 2007-Apr-24, 1am AEST
User #127599   6 posts
Forum Regular

So where can i get it cheapest?

posted 2007-May-19, 10pm AEST
User #62609   294 posts
Forum Regular

Seems almost everyone agrees Acronis True Image Home is the winner ?

Can anyone confirm it works with E6600 / Intel 956 mobo ?

posted 2007-Jun-15, 11pm AEST
User #67672   1690 posts
Whirlpool Enthusiast

effgee writes...

Seems almost everyone agrees Acronis True Image Home is the winner ?

Can anyone confirm it works with E6600 / Intel 956 mobo ?


what are you talking about? You must be kidding right?
Acronis is a software used for creating image of your hard drive i.e software related.

posted 2007-Jun-15, 11pm AEST
User #109595   2131 posts
Whirlpool Forums Addict

effgee writes...

Seems almost everyone agrees Acronis True Image Home is the winner ?

It's perfect. I can't imagine it getting any better in anyway. Did a restore a couple weeks ago. Took about 10 minutes from start to finish. Every thing seems spot on.

Can anyone confirm it works with E6600 / Intel 956 mobo ?

Why wouldn't it ? It just takes an image of your HDD. I don't see how your CPU/Mobo could affect it.

posted 2007-Jun-15, 11pm AEST
User #62609   294 posts
Forum Regular

wassam writes...

You must be kidding right?

no, not kidding, just a little short on details. I'm not talking about it running from windows.

I assume my drive will die one day and I will have to rely on boot disc to restore the system. I've used ghost for many years to do this, but the ghost recovery disc simply won't boot and run correctly on my new 965-based pc. I also tried seagate's 'discwizard' (which is basically a cut down and lightly re-badged version of acronis) and had the same thing. Hence the question.

I have resolved it now by editing the realmode cdrom driver in the boot image on my ghost recovery disc, so all is sweet again - no need for acronis.

posted 2007-Jun-17, 12am AEST
User #166695   39 posts
Forum Regular

rakem writes...

hows does Acronis TrueImage 10 home create a full image of a hard drive while it is in windows?

It's most likely using volume shadow copy. Most sector by sector imaging solutions use VSS to create images while still in windows.

posted 2007-Jun-17, 12am AEST
User #83351   32 posts
Forum Regular

I found that HT is selling it for $75 right now. Does anyone know a cheaper source for the hard copy. I found a site for download from acronis.com.au for $49.99 but I think I'd prefer the proper hard version.

posted 2007-Jun-18, 12pm AEST
User #64666   1363 posts
Whirlpool Enthusiast

Does Acronis reboot before it does a backup? A partition/disk backup.

posted 2007-Jun-18, 1pm AEST
edited 2007-Jun-18, 1pm AEST
User #109595   2131 posts
Whirlpool Forums Addict

mrsa writes...

Does Acronis reboot before it does a backup?

I think it does. Not sure 100% though. Why?
I think it would back up all the same, regardless of what apps/processes you're running at that time. Not sure though.

It reboots when it's restoring. I know that 100%
:P

posted 2007-Jun-18, 1pm AEST
User #68459   234 posts
Forum Regular

smart1999 writes...

I found that HT is selling it for $75 right now. Does anyone know a cheaper source for the hard copy. I found a site for download from acronis.com.au for $49.99 but I think I'd prefer the proper hard version.

Just download it and Burn it to a CD, its still the same as the Hard Version, that's all I do if I'm going to save money downloading..

posted 2007-Jun-18, 2pm AEST
User #65332   235 posts
Forum Regular

Acronis does not need to reboot before it starts its image. It does use the VSS, so it doesn't matter if you have programs up and running.

posted 2007-Jun-21, 4pm AEST
User #82388   2389 posts
Whirlpool Forums Addict

With Ghost you do a Restore from the CD when you buy a hard copy.
Surely you do the same with acronis true image?

If you download ATI how do you get the CD boot disk that allows one to do a full restore?

One can be in a situation that C Drive has nothing on it but one wants to do a full restore from a CD.

Thanks

posted 2007-Oct-11, 1am AEST
User #24575   6086 posts
Whirlpool Forums Addict

m8s writes...

If you download ATI how do you get the CD boot disk that allows one to do a full restore?

You burn it. I have Acronis True Image 11. It works well. Only cost me $36 too. Had to download it myself though, but just need to back up the installation file to a CD and create an emergency CD and you're done.

posted 2007-Oct-11, 1am AEST
User #74167   1847 posts
Whirlpool Enthusiast

smart1999 writes...

I found that HT is selling it for $75 right now. Does anyone know a cheaper source for the hard copy. I found a site for download from acronis.com.au for $49.99 but I think I'd prefer the proper hard version.

If you have a Maxtor or Seagate HDD and are prepared to download 105MB then look here to get it for free forum-replies.cfm?t=836797

posted 2007-Oct-11, 8am AEST
User #94769   87 posts
Forum Regular

I have used both Ghost and ATI extensively.
I found that if the hard drive you are trying to backup has errors a lot of the time Ghost will not image (just returns to windows with a backup failed message). However, ATI will sit and go over and over untill it reads the data (or at least pop up an error message). This process can often take a long time but at least it completes.

Acronis id da bomb

posted 2007-Oct-11, 8am AEST
User #90267   574 posts
Whirlpool Enthusiast

Agree with the majority of posters in this thread. Acronis gets my vote for a well designed and user friendly imaging package. I have been using ATI (V9 & V10) and Disk Director extensively. ;-)

posted 2007-Oct-11, 8am AEST
User #65332   235 posts
Forum Regular

Have been using ATI 11 Home and its been going great.

We use the Acronis Server at work for backing up our Servers and its never skipped a beat. We are very happy with it.

When one of our Servers died, we were able to use the universal restore function to recover our last backup of the server to a brand new HP server with completly different hardware. Saved us a sh#t load of time.

posted 2007-Oct-11, 9am AEST
User #35475   2140 posts
Whirlpool Forums Addict

Grackle writes...

So where can i get it cheapest?

"www.ugr.com. Make sure you use the order code of UGTIH11 when placing your order."

Cheapest I found - less than retail. $29 USD from memory

posted 2007-Oct-11, 9am AEST
User #66644   267 posts
Forum Regular

Another fan of Acronis Trueimage Home here, been using and upgrading since version 7 and it works extremely well.
The Acronis recovery manager is also a lifesaver, just hit F11 on boot and start your restore. No need for a boot cd to recover your system.
Have a read through this
www.acronis.com.au/homec...oducts/trueimage and then download the trial and give it a go.

posted 2007-Oct-11, 9am AEST
 
© Whirlpool Broadband Multimedia